UPDATED: THE SYDNEY ROOSTERS STATE OF ORIGIN REPRESENTATIVES’ REPORT CARD: GAME THREE

Queensland 12 (Thurston, Hodges tries, Thurston two goals) bt NSW 10 (McManus, Merrin tries, Maloney goal) at ANZ Stadium. Crowd: 83,813.

Source: Courier-Mail.

Mitchell Pearce

CStats: Three runs for 19 metres, one tackle bust, six kicks for 153 metres, 20 tackles and two misses.

Report: That was probably Mitchell Pearce’s last game in an Origin Jersey. He had a chance to make a statement, and while he was active and tried a few things, nothing really came off. He dropped a ball early, got caught on the fifth tackle once (when Robbie Farah wasn’t kicking it on the fourth), passed the ball too early to Josh Dugan on the right in attack on several occasions in the first half, and overall didn’t make the impact he needed to.

And aside from a few runs that ultimately went nowhere, the superb direction he gave his forwards in game one was off last night.

Adam Reynolds will be the halfback next year it would seem. But the loss was NOT Mitchell’s fault, and the viriol headed his way is nothing short of disgusting and an embarrassment for those flinging it. Robbie Farah was horrid last night and provided poor service as I will detail further on down — and he wasn’t the only one to have a shocker in what amounted to a game decided by a penalty goal.

To blame Mitch solely for the loss is flat-out wrong. I tweeted this following the game:

Tweet

That sentiment stands. He did not win them the game — far from it. But other players in the NSW team certainly did more to contribute to the Blues losing it. His report mark falls probably closer to a C- than a C+ but did nothing that warranted people singling him out for the loss, especially compared to the dumb play of others in the squad.

If it’s his last game, so be it — selfishly, he’ll be focussed solely on the Roosters, plus he’ll be at a club and among teammates that love him, and among fans who don’t hang their own out to dry.

James Maloney.

Stats: Five runs for 44 metres, eight kicks for 277 metres, 21 tackles, one missed, one penalty, one error.

BReport: The BBQ started poorly — giving away a cheap penalty for a shoulder charge on a kicking Cooper Cronk — but afterwards was superb. He bounced back from a horrid Game two to miss just the one tackle and looked dangerous with each run.

When Cordner came on, he excelled, combining off the quick play the ball from Boyd’s first run to spread it early for Jenko, before Farah inexplicably put in a kick on the fourth with momentum on their side for a rare instance.

Defensively he stood up, only missing the one tackle early during a weaving run from Slater which eventually resulted in a line break. He was clearly the better NSW half in this one and did his club and state proud.

Michael Jennings.

Stats: 10 runs for 78 metres, 27 tackles, no misses, three errors.

BReport: Mick wasn’t given any ball in the first half, running it just once and dropping another opportunity after a woeful pass from dummy half from Farah.

In the second half he was given more opportunity but failed to break the line — although he looked the man most likely last in the game once Cordner was brought on and the Chook combos started to click.

Defensively he was incredible with 27 tackles and no misses, repeatedly shutting down Hodges, who only managed to score after Jennings was forced to come in to make an earlier tackle mid-field. It was a solid outing and following his game one performance he has done enough to stamp the left centre spot as his own for NSW for as long as he wants it.

Boyd Cordner.

Stats: Eight runs for 51 metres, 12 tackles, three misses.

CReport: His stats don’t jump out and punch you in the face like they’re Merrin and you’re Tate, but the Blues looked a far better squad for 20 minutes when he came on. His quick play the ball, the best in the competition, is a genuine weapon and on several occassions the Blues were able to make an impact out wide thansk to the space the play the ball created.

He missed three tackles but none crucial, and will play Origin again. It will be very hard to keep him out of this one.

He struggled with the pace and intenisty of the game towards the end, but if you look at his stats and think he failed to make a dent, compare them to some of his teammates: Luke Lewis (nine runs, 48 metres and a torn calf muscle), Trent Merrin (nine runs, 49 metres, a try) and Aaron Woods (four runs, 18 metres). In a beaten pack he did pretty well.

And its hard to argue the eye test: they looked a better team with him out there.

Robbie Farah

Stats: Five runs for 49 metres, six kicks for 173 metres, 43 tackles, one miss, one error.

DReport: If you compared Robbie’s stats to Boyd’s, you’d say Farah was by far the better player and perhaps one of the best on field. But that’s why television exists: so we can see what the stats don’t show.

What the stats don’t show is the following: The miss led to Jonathan Thurston’s try; He threw an aimless ball which led to Jenko’s first drop; he kicked on the fourth with momentum on their side following a mini-break from Jennings; a first tackle, ridiculous hail-mary kick to the wing with 30 seconds left with the game on the line; incredibly woeful service out of dummy half which retarded any momentum the Blues rarely had; and a lack of awareness around the ruck in taking advantage of slow marker play in the second half.

Oh, and while this is an unofficial stat, there was this tweet:

Farah

I might be alone in this — and believe me, this is not a ploy to get Mitch off the hook — but I truly believe it was one of the dumber games played by an individual in an Origin decider. He has had some superb games at Origin level but this was by far his worst.

FThe Streaker.

Stats: Two balls, three inches, two spare tires, two titties, two minutes to go, one scrum, six again.

Report: Fuckwit.

Stats sourced from The Sydney Morning Herald:

STATS Attack Defence

Advertisements

3 responses to “UPDATED: THE SYDNEY ROOSTERS STATE OF ORIGIN REPRESENTATIVES’ REPORT CARD: GAME THREE

  1. Couldn’t agree more Jake…
    Farah’s tendency for ad-lib football and his penchant for brain dead plays gave this Blues side no chance all series in fact. In game 2 he did the same, taking a number of kicks himself from dummy half when opportunities were presenting themselves. Pearce and Maloney only getting otherwise ordinary service when there was nothing on.
    While Farah is a poor excuse as a footballer IMO, he’s not the reason NSW lost yet another series. His performance only exemplifies the real problem.
    The problem… take a bow Daley and Fulton. You bring together a side year after year and ask them to give their all which they do. You run a few practice drills at training, catch/pass/catch as preparation like an A-grade side at a knockout comp and then spend more time on the hype, beating up NSW chances and why they’ll win. Congratulations you pair of dropkicks.
    I feel for the NSW players. As always they give 110% each and every one. And as always they’re given no game plan, have no weapons in they’re arsenal and left to carry the inevitable can. Daley can hardly string together a coherent sentence, never lone publicly accept responsibility for the disaster.
    I’ll repeat the comments I made about MP7 after game 2. I hope now he stands down from origin football altogether and concentrates on footy with the Roosters. Not for selfish reasons, but because with this sort of coaching/selector personnel at NSW he’ll always be on a hiding to nothing. Back to where you are understood and admirably supported Mitch. Please.

    Like

    • Agree with everything — and i think it’s now time that Reynolds gets the shot in the Number 7. His kicking game is savant-like and he offers something in attack that Mitch doesn’t have. Mitch’s strengths — passing, taking the line on — haven’t been on show, and he ran it just three times last night for no impact. Reynolds could do just about the same thing.

      Mitch’s defence was again fantastic, and will be missed at this level when Reynolds is promoted. But Mitch, aside from an excellent game one, has not taken a game and influenced it with any of his attacking strengths.

      (And sorry mate — had to remove the cement truck reference although i did enjoy it given the Fulton Corollary [i just don’t want to be sued:) ] )

      Like

  2. Pingback: Sydney Roosters State of Origin Representative's Report Card: Game three - We Love League·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s